<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8" ?>
<rdf:RDF xmlns:rdf="http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#" xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:syn="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/syndication/" xmlns="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/">




    



<channel rdf:about="https://netzwerkit2.free.de/search_rss">
  <title>Netzwerk IT</title>
  <link>https://netzwerkit2.free.de</link>

  <description>
    
            These are the search results for the query, showing results 1 to 4.
        
  </description>

  

  

  <image rdf:resource="https://netzwerkit2.free.de/logo.png"/>

  <items>
    <rdf:Seq>
      
        <rdf:li rdf:resource="https://netzwerkit2.free.de/projekte/waterman/AutobioBiblio4Interface040516"/>
      
      
        <rdf:li rdf:resource="https://netzwerkit2.free.de/projekte/waterman/WatermanEricLeeProudZionist"/>
      
      
        <rdf:li rdf:resource="https://netzwerkit2.free.de/projekte/waterman/the-dance-of-the-undead"/>
      
      
        <rdf:li rdf:resource="https://netzwerkit2.free.de/projekte/waterman/caracas-report"/>
      
    </rdf:Seq>
  </items>

</channel>


  <item rdf:about="https://netzwerkit2.free.de/projekte/waterman/AutobioBiblio4Interface040516">
    <title>Social Movement Auto/Biographies:</title>
    <link>https://netzwerkit2.free.de/projekte/waterman/AutobioBiblio4Interface040516</link>
    <description>A Rough Guide to Sources and Resources //
Peter Waterman
peterwaterman1936@gmail.com</description>
    
    <dc:publisher>No publisher</dc:publisher>
    <dc:creator>Peter Waterman</dc:creator>
    <dc:rights></dc:rights>
    <dc:date>2016-05-29T16:18:56Z</dc:date>
    <dc:type>Datei</dc:type>
  </item>


  <item rdf:about="https://netzwerkit2.free.de/projekte/waterman/WatermanEricLeeProudZionist">
    <title>Eric Lee: The Online Labour Solidarity Whiz who’s ‘Proud to be a Zionist’</title>
    <link>https://netzwerkit2.free.de/projekte/waterman/WatermanEricLeeProudZionist</link>
    <description>Eric Lee is best-known as the owner/coordinator of two international labour
sites online. LabourStart is a unique and humungous news and solidarity site,
fed by hundreds of volunteers. It is heavily identified with the Eurocentric and
Social-Liberal International Trade Union Confederation (ITUC). UnionBook
is his pinboard or sandbox, on which contributors can</description>
    
    <dc:publisher>No publisher</dc:publisher>
    <dc:creator>Peter Waterman</dc:creator>
    <dc:rights></dc:rights>
    <dc:date>2016-04-22T16:54:27Z</dc:date>
    <dc:type>Datei</dc:type>
  </item>


  <item rdf:about="https://netzwerkit2.free.de/projekte/waterman/the-dance-of-the-undead">
    <title>The Dance of the Undead</title>
    <link>https://netzwerkit2.free.de/projekte/waterman/the-dance-of-the-undead</link>
    <description>Not only at Marikana, Not only in South Africa...</description>
    <content:encoded xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/"><![CDATA[<p>Peter Waterman</p>
<p><a class="reference external" href="mailto:peterwaterman1936@gmail.com">peterwaterman1936&#64;gmail.com</a></p>
<pre class="literal-block">
The term undead describes beings in mythology, legend or fiction that
are deceased yet behave as if alive. A common example is a corpse
re-animated by supernatural forces by the application of the deceased's
own life force or that of another being (such as a demon). Undead may
be incorporeal like ghosts, or corporeal like vampires and zombies.'
(Wikipedia)
</pre>
<div class="section" id="introduction-1">
<h3>Introduction <a class="footnote-reference" href="#id6" id="id1">[1]</a></h3>
<p>I can still remember my fury and frustration after hearing of the Sharpeville Massacre, 1960. I had attended Communist student conferences with the charismatic Albie Sachs. And I took part in Anti-Apartheid protests in the UK along with Kadar Asmal. Both, regrettably, eventually found their homes in the problematic post-Apartheid regime in South Africa.</p>
<p>I also have recognise responsibility for my longtime commitment to three global movements that in Marikana have been exposed as naked under their empty rhetoric, within their uniforms, behind their flags – now co-responsible for their very own Sharpeville.</p>
<p>Before expanding on this I have to say that my involvement with and knowledge about South Africa has, over the decades, been only for certain periods and - except for the post-Apartheid years - at a distance. Both before and after the end of Apartheid, it has been primarily with or through movements of international solidarity, mostly those of labour. But because of a cosmopolitan Jewish Communist background and involvement with a range of South Africans involved in social struggles there, South Africa has always been on my mind.</p>
<p>Confronted, August 2012 with the Marikana Massacre, I could not but recall this poem of W.H. Auden, about the August of the Soviet invasion that I experienced in Prague, 1968.</p>
<pre class="literal-block">
The Ogre does what ogres can,
Deeds quite impossible for Man,
But one prize is beyond his reach:
The Ogre cannot master speech.

About a subjugated plain,
Among its desperate and slain,
The Ogre stalks with hands on hips,
While drivel gushes from his lips.
</pre>
</div>
<div class="section" id="the-three-party-alliance-and-the-mec-makes-four">
<h3>The Three-Party Alliance – and the MEC makes Four</h3>
<p>The South African state is governed by a tripartite alliance of three 20th century (or earlier) movements with emancipatory claims, projecting each its own utopia:</p>
<ol class="arabic simple">
<li>The African National Congress promising a utopia of national citizens (‘the people shall govern’);</li>
<li>Cosatu promising a labourist utopia (more recently, full employment and ‘quality jobs’);</li>
<li>A Communist Party promising ‘to end the system of capitalist exploitation and establish a socialist republic based on the common ownership of the means of production <a class="footnote-reference" href="#id7" id="id2">[2]</a></li>
</ol>
<p>But there is a very real fourth party to the alliance. This is the Minerals, Energy (and Financial) Complex (MEC), the one that has best survived and most benefited from the end of Apartheid. And whilst invisible in the Tripartite Alliance, and the Constitution, its vampire role has been dramatically revealed by the Marikana Massacre.</p>
<p>Now, when an irresistible force meets an immovable object, something’s got to give. In this case the force has been 21st century capitalism, red in tooth and claw. And the immovable objects in the Tripartite Alliance have revealed themselves as extremely mutable.</p>
<p>The nature, process and outcome of the transition from Apartheid have been well identified by critical writers in South Africa, in such phrases as ‘Elite Transition’ (Patrick Bond) ‘Lost in Transformation’ (Sampie Terreblanche on the MEC), ‘Coup by the Connected and Corrupt’ (Mark Heywood on the undermining of the Constitution), ‘Gaining Influence, Losing Power’ (Sakhela Buhlungu on Cosatu), ‘The end of the anti-apartheid democratic labour movement’ (Khanya Journal on Cosatu), ‘A Vanguard of ANC Factionalism’ (Dale McKinley on the SACP). For all of these and a multiplicity of other voices, check the frequent compilations on Marikana posted on the invaluable South African Debate List.</p>
</div>
<div class="section" id="some-features-tendencies-of-21st-century-capitalism">
<h3>Some features/tendencies of 21st century capitalism</h3>
<p>If national, labour, communist and labourist utopias are running out of any conceivable emancipatory potential, this is because of the ongoing capitalist revolution. It is mostly identified in terms of globalisation and neo-liberalism (actually palaeo-liberalism). To these features we have to add informatisation, financialisation, tercerisation and precarisation. Allied with these are</p>
<ul class="simple">
<li>The combination of political democracy and social fascism (Boaventura de Sousa Santos);</li>
<li>The emptying out of even that political democracy, as shown by the speed of state bank bail-outs (too big to fail) at the cost of the poor (too weak to resist);</li>
<li>Increasing commodification, the relationship between human beings being ever-more that of the cash nexus, signified by the increasing conversion of the citizen into a consumer (following 9/11 the US President urged a traumatised population ‘to go shopping’)</li>
<li>The failure to even slow ecological devastation, with radical action systematically stymied at inter-state conferences, this accompanied with an the increasing flow of ‘greenwash’;</li>
<li>Increasing waves of ethnocentrism, racism, xenophobia;</li>
<li>Increasing local, national, international violence, where the implicit justification is the 19th century colonial one: ‘The difference is that we have got the Gatling gun and they have not’. And, of course, there are those international courts in The Hague, concentrating on the small-scale African or Balkan criminals, whilst unable to touch the big British and American ones.</li>
</ul>
</div>
<div class="section" id="not-only-in-south-africa">
<h3>Not only in South Africa</h3>
<p>The present crisis of capitalist civilisation may be sharper and more dramatic in South Africa than elsewhere. This is obviously due to the equally dramatic replacement of the Apartheid state by a liberal-democratic/social-liberal one. And to the relative novelty, fragility and contradictions within and between the three parties named. The result? Political democracy and social fascism indeed!</p>
<p>However, the crisis striking the three identified parties is not unique to South Africa:</p>
<ul class="simple">
<li>In the South, consider the case of Brazil, where the working-class composition of the Workers Party was transformed into one of the rising middle class. The CUT (trade union) and Worker Party President, Lula da Silva, has combined significant redistribution (Bolsa Familia) to the poorest of the poor with neo-liberal economic policies. But the income differentials continue to rival those of South Africa. And meanwhile we witness the Rise and Decline of Brazil’s New Unionism (Jeffrey Sluyter-Beltrao 2010).</li>
<li>In the East – the Communist homeland - we witness either, 1) the seriously illiberal democracy of a Russia in which the former state-controlled unions are hamstrung by their devotion to tripartism and crippled by privatisation and deindustrialisation, and where power rests with ex-KGB apparatchiki (Soviet origin of the Machista Prime President), favoured oligarchs and a state-subservient church, or 2) The self-transformation of the Chinese Communist party and state into a corrupt authoritarian industrialising capitalist regime, presiding over state-subordinated trade unions – whilst labour and popular protest movements rival those of South Africa.</li>
<li>In Western Europe we have seen the collapse of mass Communist and Social-Democratic parties, the crisis of trade unions wedded to social-partnership and the capitalist welfare state, crippled by privatisation, precarisation, anti-labour legislation, and outsourcing. Whilst most-clearly evident in semi-peripheral Greece and Spain, the poverty and anti-labour legislation in these countries is leaking upstream to the social-reformist heartland.</li>
</ul>
</div>
<div class="section" id="is-another-south-africa-and-world-possible">
<h3>Is another South Africa (and world) possible?</h3>
<p>The undead do not die. These corpses can be ‘re-animated by supernatural forces by the application of the deceased's own life force’. This supernatural is, in South Africa, actually social - the inertial force of what exists over what is yet to be born.</p>
<p>What is, however, surely demonstrated by the dance of the undead in South Africa is the necessity for another emancipatory movement, with another kind of utopia. Confronted with dystopia, we are condemned to being utopian (Sousa Santos again).</p>
<p>This means the re-imagination of emancipation, this time without the illusion that capitalism, state-ism, industrialism, modernisation, developmentalism, represent or allow for human flourishing, for a reinvention of Ubuntu, <a class="footnote-reference" href="#id8" id="id3">[3]</a> for rights granted also to Pachamama (Mother Earth in the Andes), of emancipation as the overcoming of all forms of alienation (the destruction of previous rights and powers, the denial of present capacities and future human possibilities).</p>
<p>Invisible or emergent in South Africa well before Marikana (as elsewhere) are social protests, movements, networks, writings that propose such elements of human emancipation as</p>
<ul class="simple">
<li>the democratisation of democracy (recognising this as something that must spread and deepen or shrivel and die),</li>
<li>the protection and expansion of the commons,</li>
<li>useful (as distinguished from ‘decent’) work, requiring the surpassing of wage-slavery</li>
<li>the active acceptance (not passive tolerance) of sexual minorities,</li>
<li>an equal dialogue of civilisations instead of a war of Gatling gun wielders against the Others,</li>
<li>global solidarity movements owned by those addressed (not their jet-setting leaders)</li>
<li>universal disarmament, beginning with unilateral acts,</li>
<li>consumption serving human needs and ecological flourishing,</li>
<li>the real - rather than token, commoditised or fetishised - emancipation of women,</li>
<li>the emancipation of cyberspace</li>
<li>(fill as required)</li>
</ul>
<p>The undead do not commit suicide. They have not only their own ‘life force’ but their own – conservative or reactionary – utopias.</p>
<p>Within the left and labour movements of South Africa (and elsewhere) this utopia is a backward-looking one, the explicit or implicit reference of which is a 1970s Sweden (idealised). This unexamined utopia is universalised and projected onto the world stage. It is here best represented by that Mecca of ‘social partnership’, the International Labour Organisation (another Tripartite Alliance, in which the self-subordination of unionised labour is signified by the century-old 75% voting power of state and capital). The dream, however, of a Global Neo-Keynesianism does not take account of 1) why it has run into the ground in its North-West European homeland nor, 2) whether it could possibly be hoisted to the global level, nor 3) of the self- and us-destructive nature of capitalism, whether Keynesian or Friedmanite.</p>
</div>
<div class="section" id="is-another-emancipatory-movement-possible">
<h3>Is another emancipatory movement possible?</h3>
<pre class="literal-block">
Marcos is gay in San Francisco, Black in South Africa,
an Asian in  Europe, a Chicano in San Ysidro, an anarchist in Spain,
a Palestinian in Israel, a Mayan Indian in the streets of San Cristobal,
a Jew in Germany, a Gypsy in Poland, a Mohawk in Quebec,
a pacifist in Bosnia, a single woman on the Metro at 10pm,
a peasant without land, a gang member in the slums, an unemployed worker,
an unhappy student and, of course, a Zapatista in the mountains.

Marcos is all the exploited, marginalised, oppressed minorities
resisting and saying 'Enough'. He is every minority who is now beginning
to speak and every majority that must shut up and listen. He is every
untolerated group searching for a way to speak. Everything that makes
power and the good consciences of those in power uncomfortable — this is
Marcos. (Subcomandante Marcos [Rafael Sebastián Guillén Vicente] 1997)
</pre>
<p>Expressed poetically (and individualistically), from the mountains of South-Western Mexico, this is a powerful evocation and prescient expression of the new emancipatory movement(s) that have spread worldwide a decade and more later. They have their often momentary, weak or inchoate expressions in South Africa. And as Naomi Klein commented on this text later, it expresses an anti-elitist notion of leadership: ‘we are the leader we’ve been looking for’.</p>
<p>Trade unionists and other labour vanguardists may be disappointed that he didn’t mention them, or employed workers, at all! But maybe this will provoke them to reflect on an organisational form and occupational status that today provides no privileged emancipatory role. Trade unions, for that matter, can today only effectively defend themselvesw within and under capitalism insofar as both the union organisation and class-category re-invent themselves in the light of what Marcos here suggests. In so articulating themselves primarily with the other exploited and alienated, they may contribute to the construction of an emancipatory movement that has learnt from the limitations and disappointments of the traditional nationalist, communist and trade union movements.</p>
<p>Note that the sense of intersectional <a class="footnote-reference" href="#id9" id="id4">[4]</a> solidarity expressed by Marcos is also internationalist. It suggests the interdependence of those identified.</p>
<p>Such an understanding is to be contrasted with that of at least the SACP and the ANC, whose complicity with the Soviet invasion of its Communist ally, Czechoslovakia, 1968, was at least implicitly justified by the prioritisation of national liberation over and against solidarity with workers and peoples subject to Soviet imperialism. Cosatu and its predecessor, Fosatu, having been born after (and actually despite) ANC-SACP domination of the anti-apartheid movement in general and the union movement in particular, supported the Polish workers against the Communist-Military Dictatorship of Jaruzelski, and, more recently, has taken dramatic action against Chinese Communist arms shipments to the authoritarian regime of Mugabe in Zimbabwe. Cosatu has also shown itself willing to openly debate its international relations. The possibility therefore still exists of Cosatu breaking out of the iron cage of traditional union elite inter-nationalism and contributing to a new kind of global solidarity unionism (Waterman 2012).</p>
</div>
<div class="section" id="conclusion-beyond-marx">
<h3>Conclusion: beyond Marx</h3>
<p>Communism is for us not a state of affairs which is to be established, an ideal to which reality [will] have to adjust itself. We call communism the real movement which abolishes the present state of things. The conditions of this movement result from the premises now in existence. (Marx 1845)</p>
<p>Karl Marx, the 19th century prophet of emancipation and international solidarity, based on industrial capitalism’s production of its own gravediggers, the industrial proletariat, got this wrong. <a class="footnote-reference" href="#id10" id="id5">[5]</a> As he did about the conditions for this movement being then in existence. Where, however, this passage speaks to us today is in its declaration that emancipation is not a state of affairs (or an affair of states?), that it is not an ideal (preached on behalf of the exploited by intellectual or political vanguards). Nor, given its embodiment in states (mostly collapsed due to their oppression of workers and peoples), in ideas (mostly archaic dogma in the mouths of those substituting for the workers, the people). It does however, provoke us to ask whether the premises for a global (holistic as well as worldwide and cyberspatial) movement are not now in existence. And then to address ourselves to, identify with and take part in ‘the real movement that abolishes the present state of things’. And this not only in South Africa.</p>
</div>
<div class="section" id="resources">
<h3>Resources</h3>
<p>[This is not a detailed bibliography but a list of resources, including relevant books, that should be useful to those interested to follow up the essay. PW]</p>
<p>Bond, Patrick. 2000. The Elite Transition: From Apartheid to Neoliberalism in South Africa. London: Pluto. And <a class="reference external" href="http://ccs.ukzn.ac.za/files/Bond%20Elite%20Transition%202ndEdn.pdf">http://ccs.ukzn.ac.za/files/Bond%20Elite%20Transition%202ndEdn.pdf</a>.</p>
<p>Buhlungu, Sakhela. 2010. ‘Gaining Influence, Losing Power: Cosatu’s Contested Future’, Chapter 8, A Paradox of Victory: Cosatu and the Democratic Transformation in South Africa. Scottsville: University of Kwazulu-Natal Press.</p>
<p>Crenshaw, Kimberlé. 1993. ‘Mapping the Margins: Intersectionality, Identity Politics, and Violence Against Women of Color’. <a class="reference external" href="http://www.socialdifference.org/files/active/0/Article__Mapping_the_Margins_by_Kimblere_Crenshaw.pdf">http://www.socialdifference.org/files/active/0/Article__Mapping_the_Margins_by_Kimblere_Crenshaw.pdf</a>. And <a class="reference external" href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersectionality">http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersectionality</a>.</p>
<p>Harvey, Ebrahim. 2007. ‘Whither the Congress of South African Trade Unions?’. <a class="reference external" href="http://www.solidarity-us.org/site/node/460">http://www.solidarity-us.org/site/node/460</a>.</p>
<p>Heywood, Mark. 2012. ‘Coup by the Connected and Corrupt’. Mail and Guardian. August 31. <a class="reference external" href="http://mg.co.za/article/2012-08-31-00-coup-by-the-connected-and-corrupt/">http://mg.co.za/article/2012-08-31-00-coup-by-the-connected-and-corrupt/</a>.</p>
<p>Khanya Journal. 2012. ‘Editorial Statement: From Ficksburg to Marikana: South Africa’s Post-Apartheid Democracy on Trial! <a class="reference external" href="http://www.ngopulse.org/press-release/khanya-journal-editorial-statement-marikana-massacre">http://www.ngopulse.org/press-release/khanya-journal-editorial-statement-marikana-massacre</a>.</p>
<p>Macpherson, C. B. 1962. The Political Theory of Possessive Individualism : From Hobbes to Locke. Oxford: Oxford University Press.</p>
<p>Marcos, Subcomandante. <a class="reference external" href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subcomandante_Marcos">http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subcomandante_Marcos</a>
Marx, Karl. 1845. The German Ideology. <a class="reference external" href="http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1845/german-ideology/ch01a.htm">http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1845/german-ideology/ch01a.htm</a></p>
<p>McKinley, Dale. 2012. ‘The Struggle of Memory against Forgetting: How the SACP Has Become a Vanguard of ANC Power Factionalism’. <a class="reference external" href="http://sacsis.org.za/s/stories.php?iLive=09.2012">http://sacsis.org.za/s/stories.php?iLive=09.2012</a>.</p>
<p>Sluyter-Beltrao, Jeffrey. 2010. Rise and Decline of Brazil’s New Unionism: The Politics of the Central Única dos Trabalhadores. Basel: Peter Lang.</p>
<p>Terreblanche, Sampie. 2012. Lost in Transformation: South Africa's Search for a New Future since 1986. Sandton:  KMM Review Publishing Company.</p>
<table class="docutils footnote" frame="void" id="id6" rules="none">
<colgroup><col class="label"><col></colgroup>
<tbody valign="top">
<tr><td class="label"><a class="fn-backref" href="#id1">[1]</a></td><td>I here expand on my comments at the final panel of the African National Congress 100th Anniversary Conference, held at the International Institute of Social Studies, The Hague, September 10, 2012. It was a useful and mostly critical academic event. I had been tempted to call for a two-minute silence that I am sure would have been accepted by the overwhelming majority of conference participants. It could have turned a critical academic analytical event into a global civil society or social movement one.</td></tr>
</tbody>
</table>
<table class="docutils footnote" frame="void" id="id7" rules="none">
<colgroup><col class="label"><col></colgroup>
<tbody valign="top">
<tr><td class="label"><a class="fn-backref" href="#id2">[2]</a></td><td>The major 20th century movement missing here is the Social-Democratic (now social-liberal), incremental, one, often in office but never in power, and today represented by a congeries of left-neo-liberal parties, promising, at best, a return to or revival of some Swedish Utopia of the 1970s, now on a world scale. We should also not forget the literally reactionary apocalyptical religious social movements, nor the political-populist movements – ‘right’ or ‘left’ - both with their explicit or implicit utopias, the latter represented at Marikana and in South Africa more generally by the charismatic Julius Malema.</td></tr>
</tbody>
</table>
<table class="docutils footnote" frame="void" id="id8" rules="none">
<colgroup><col class="label"><col></colgroup>
<tbody valign="top">
<tr><td class="label"><a class="fn-backref" href="#id3">[3]</a></td><td>The Ubuntu notion, that I am who I am because of other people, would seem to be in polar opposition to the liberal bourgeois notion that I am who I am despite other people – ‘the political theory of possessive individualism’ (C.B. Macpherson 1962). An emancipatory ontology might require a synthesis or surpassing of the suggested opposition.</td></tr>
</tbody>
</table>
<table class="docutils footnote" frame="void" id="id9" rules="none">
<colgroup><col class="label"><col></colgroup>
<tbody valign="top">
<tr><td class="label"><a class="fn-backref" href="#id4">[4]</a></td><td>‘Intersectionality’ (Kimberle Crenshaw 1989) is a Black feminist concept from the USA. Despite its apparent blandness, it undermines the notion of a homogenous ‘woman’ (or ‘worker’?) and argues the interdependence of the multiple forms of oppression.</td></tr>
</tbody>
</table>
<table class="docutils footnote" frame="void" id="id10" rules="none">
<colgroup><col class="label"><col></colgroup>
<tbody valign="top">
<tr><td class="label"><a class="fn-backref" href="#id5">[5]</a></td><td>In South Africa, followers of Marx (plus Lenin and/or Trotsky) nonetheless continue to prioritise both ‘point of production’ struggles and formation of a workers’ party. See the otherwise quite 21st century critique of Cosatu and analysis of the new social movements by Ebrahim Harvey (2007). The party model he recommends is, significantly and unfortunately, that of the Brazilian PT!</td></tr>
</tbody>
</table>
</div>
]]></content:encoded>
    <dc:publisher>No publisher</dc:publisher>
    <dc:creator>Peter Waterman</dc:creator>
    <dc:rights></dc:rights>
    <dc:date>2012-09-17T19:15:11Z</dc:date>
    <dc:type>Seite</dc:type>
  </item>


  <item rdf:about="https://netzwerkit2.free.de/projekte/waterman/caracas-report">
    <title>From Unity to Emancipation?</title>
    <link>https://netzwerkit2.free.de/projekte/waterman/caracas-report</link>
    <description>Labour at the World Forum of Alternatives Conference,
Caracas, October 13-18, 2008</description>
    <content:encoded xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/"><![CDATA[
<p align="center"><strong><img class="image-inline" src="copy_of_c.png/image_preview" alt="caracas" /><br /></strong></p>
<p align="center"><strong>Peter
Waterman</strong><sup><strong><a class="sdfootnoteanc" name="sdfootnote1anc" href="#sdfootnote1sym"><sup>1</sup></a></strong></sup></p>
<p align="center"><a href="mailto:p.waterman@inter.nl.net">p.waterman@inter.nl.net</a></p>
<p align="center">&nbsp;</p>
<h3>Introduction</h3>
<p>	As
a researcher/activist on labour and internationalism, I have been
both engaging with and writing on the increasing articulation of
labour with/in the global justice and solidarity movement. Autumn
2008 there were at least three international events dealing with this
relationship. One was the <em>European
Social Forum</em>
in Malmo, Sweden, the second was an international union conference,
<em>Union
Alliances with Social Movements: What's in It for Us?</em>,
in Oslo, Norway (<strong>Appendix
A)</strong>.
The third was an international conference co-sponsored by the World
Forum of Alternatives (WFA) with the Venezuelan state-supported
International Encounter of Intellectuals and Artists in Defence of
Humanity (Defence of Humanity), <em>Transitions
Toward Socialism: Political, Economic, Social and Cultural Aspects</em>,
Caracas, Venezuela. I attended the first (Waterman 2008a) and had to
choose between the second two, deciding for Caracas.</p>
<p>	On
the face of it, this was a paradoxical option since I have been
publicly critical of the WFA and its leading figure, Samir Amin (Sen
and Kumar 2007, Waterman 2008b), as well as of state-promoted
socialisms (insurrectionary or incrementalist, North and South, East
and West). Having once burned my fingers on Stalin, I am not
enchanted by personalistic leaders, however revolutionary,
anti-imperialist, intellectually brilliant or outrageous they might
happen to be. So why did I prefer the conference of intellectuals
organised by Samir Amin and François
Houtart, and hosted by President Hugo Chávez?</p>
<p>After
all, the occurrence
of the rather more Social-Democratic Oslo event was gratifying for
someone who, for two decades, has been arguing for the inter/national
unions to be closely articulated with the new global solidarity
movements. And the initiator of the small Oslo event, the Norwegian
unionist and social activist, Asbjørn
Wahl, might have been pissed at my favouring the large Caracas one –
where my absence would have made a very small hole in the water.</p>
<p>	I
was certainly
intrigued by the interest Samir Amin had privately expressed in my
Global Labour Charter (Waterman 2008c). It is, moreover, true that
despite my general criticism of both the content and form of the
WFA's various charters or appeals, I did and do still think that the
brief labour chapter in the WFA's Bamako Appeal, drafted by the
Swedish Ingemar Lindberg, is the most innovative one available
<strong>(Appendix
B)</strong>.
And I <em>had</em>
been invited by the organisers to act as discussant within the Labour
workshop. Only lastly did I consider it intriguing to explore what
basis a 19<sup>th</sup>
and 20<sup>th</sup>
century socialism (supplemented by the 21<sup>st</sup>
century socialist project of Hugo Chávez) might provide for
launching an autonomous 21<sup>st</sup>
century labour movement and internationalism, free of past
inadequacies, not to speak of misdemeanours and crimes (Social
Democratic and National-Populist as well as Communist).</p>
<p><strong>	</strong>With
minimal pomp and circumstance we 130 or so intellectuals (mostly
Southern) gathered at what was once the five-star Hilton Hotel in the
middle of Caracas (it might have dropped a star or two but it was
nonetheless a luxurious and well-equipped venue). Others will
describe and evaluate the conference as a whole, as also the meeting
with Hugo Chávez, and any impressions they gained of Venezuela
itself. There is certainly much more to the Venezuelan experience
than might be suggested by this extract from a pro-Chávez newspaper:</p>
<p>
The Venezuelan
Revolution depends on Comandante Chavez. This affirmation…is</p>
<p>
indisputable:
If we could even imagine for a moment this Revolution without Chavez,
we would quickly realise that he is indispensable...Anything that
attacks the leadership of Chavez, attacks the Revolution. To be with
Chavez means to be with everything he decides! <strong>
</strong>(Aponte
2008. My translation - PW).</p>
<p>But
I
have to leave such matters to those better qualified to talk about
the host country and its leader, some of which can be found in the
references and resources below.</p>
<p>But
even if I concentrate
on the labour question at the conference this still requires placing
it in context of its other parts. The agenda covered:</p>
<ol>
<ol><li>
<p>Unity
		of labour</p>
</li><li>
<p>The
		Agrarian question</p>
</li><li>
<p>Democracy,
		equality, fundamental
		rights, gender</p>
</li><li>
<p>Cultural
		pluralism, religion, ethics, ethnicity, communication, language,
		mass media</p>
</li><li>
<p>World
		Economic Order</p>
</li><li>
<p>World
		International Order</p>
</li><li>
<p>Regionalisation
		and integration</p>
</li><li>
<p>Economic,
		social and political transition</p>
</li></ol>
</ol>
<p>	Here
I note: 1) that only one social movement is directly addressed, that
of labour; 2) that over half of humankind, women, have no room of
their own; 3) that the following three questions are about
inter-state relations, in policy terms; 4) that the 'transition' is
implicitly
to Venezuelan socialism (surely only one possible model?). Even if,
however, organisers and participants were agreed on the
desirability/inevitability of <em>some</em>
kind of socialism, the question still remains of why this requires
consideration of only one social movement.</p>
<p>	I
note, in addition to the marginalisation of women, the absence of
certain other movements or even 'questions': Ecology, Peace,
Indigineity, Sexuality and Internationalism (except, marginally, the
internationalism of labour!), And, for a conference inspired by
Marxist political-economy, there is, surely a gaping hole (or Wall of
Berlin?) where computerisation/informatisation should be. Without the
creation of cyberspace, industrial and financial globalisation - and
contemporary imperial surveillance, military and cultural hegemony -
is inconceivable. And so, indeed, would be the present power and
flexibility - and the future potential - of counter-hegemonic
movements, particularly the global ones. Indeed, this conference and
the WFA themselves - as well as any spin-off from, or feedback to
such - are barely conceivable without this new space of networking
and struggle. Traditional anti-imperialism and even anti-capitalism,
may have no need for this hypothesis. But cyberspace is surely a
crucial arena, operating according to a networking logic, essential
for global social emancipation in the 21<sup>st</sup>
century (Castells 1996-1997).</p>
<p>	I
later had the strong feeling that, if the agenda was over-specified,
the procedure was under-planned. The verbal advice, from either the
platform or across the breakfast table, was to both theorise and
strategise. Unless, however, one had experience with or access to
previous WFA declarations or the relevant writings of Samir Amin
(e.g. Amin 2008), this was a licence to shoot at anything within
sight and range. And, furthermore, there was no shape or limit
suggested for the length or time of the eventual workshop
report-backs. As a result, some were relatively short and crisp,
others were long, vague and even boring. But I am here leapfrogging
over the workshops.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<h3><strong>The
labour workshop</strong></h3>
<p>	I
should be less picky about the address to social movements. These did
creep into other topics and labour, at least, was here not a question
but a movement. And, I must say, it also had 20-25 rather varied and
well-qualified participants, including one or two from China (current
Olympic champion in industrial, urban and rural labour protest!). We
were, perhaps, missing only Venezuela itself, even if a
North-American specialist, Michael Lebowitz (see Lebowitz 2008), made
thought-provoking contributions. But, given the complex and changing
situation within the labour movement in Venezuela (search
<u><a href="http://www.venezuelanalysis.com/analysis/labor">http://www.venezuelanalysis.com/analysis/labor</a></u>),
perhaps they were either uninvited or too preoccupied to attend.</p>
<p>	The
organisers had sub-divided our two-day working group into three
sub-groups: 1) The working class and the world of work; 2)
South-South solidarity, union internationalism and social movements;
and 3) New forms of labour organisation in a society in transition
(here to rather than from socialism).  Whatever the initiators'
intentions, the group decided to remain in plenary session and then,
in practice, to adapt the sub-topics, so that the latter two dealt
with labour internationalisms on all axes, and with new forms of
labour self-organisation more generally (although evidently in the
light of socialism). The group coordinator, South African labour
specialist and former unionist, Devan Pillay, spoke from the
conclusions to a new book itself introduced by Samir Amin (Bieler,
Lindberg and Pillay 2008). As discussant I added a plea for a global
labour charter that would be inspired by a current womens' one, and
would surpass the limitations of the hegemonic international unions'
'Decent Work' campaign (Waterman 2008c).</p>
<p>	The
following discussion was both rich and chaotic. I thought it would
have been much more fruitful and, indeed, capable of summary, if we
had had the labour chapter of the Bamako Appeal on the table to
either amend, reject or replace. I was cheered, actually, by the
number of experiences and arguments coming from labour organisations,
networks or movements that seemed to be recognising both the
increasing diversity of 'work-for-capital' and of worker interests,
protests and demands going ‘beyond the factory gates and the walls
of the union office’ (Haworth and Ramsay 1984). At the same time, I
began to get the impression that two traditions were being
represented in the overwhelmingly friendly exchange. One was the
historical Marxist/socialist/unionist one, the other more inspired by
the new social movements and emancipatory theories. Given that, in
practice, both tendencies referred to Marx and socialism, I later
conceived this as a difference between a classical ‘Marxist
Political-Economic’ and a ‘Marxist Alienation’ approach to
labour (for me the first suggests a reductionist approach to human
emancipation, the second a holistic one).</p>
<p>	A
draft statement was produced by Devan, myself and Meena Menon (a
long-term Marxist- political and labour-movement activist from
Western India). Presented to a conference plenary, this was then
subject to further discussion in the labour group. The
'historical/political-economic/whatever' group felt unrepresented in
the draft and was encouraged to formulate its additions or
alternatives. This they did, but then handed in a redraft in which I
could barely identify the fine changes they had made! Perhaps this
suggests that any such differences as there might have been amongst
us did not amount to those between parties or factions but crossed
the divide I had in my mind.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<h3><strong>The
labour declaration</strong></h3>
<p>	The
labour chapter is attached as <strong>Appendix
D</strong>.
I find it a somewhat impressionistic rather than a theoretical,
analytical or prescriptive statement – even if such elements are
present. But the impression it gives, I think, is of a new world of
labour, new language for talking about this, and new forms of
self-organisation and action being taken. It is, for me, significant
that the title has changed from 'Unity of Workers' to 'Toward the
Emancipation of Labour'. This may be because the first is the limited
ideal that brought unions to merge in the little-known International
Trade Union Confederation in 2006. It is also because 'emancipation'
is both an old and new social movement slogan that provokes questions
about how, what and why (for example: why we need unity, what kind of
unity and how we should unify). I consider the references to cases
here so telegraphic as to be possibly misleading. The one to China
hardly explains why there has been so <em>much
</em>labour
protest there. And that to Venezuela brushes over tensions and
conflicts between worker types and leaderships that were, if briefly,
mentioned in the workshop. However, I am happy to find reference to
social movement unionism, and to possible global labour charters. I
was, indeed, sure that one or more on migrant workers already existed
(and later found this recent one,
<u><a href="http://www.migrantwatch.org/index.html">http://www.migrantwatch.org/index.html</a></u>).
 In any case, the report was a result of group work and survived
differences of opinion. So I am quite willing to be associated with
it. Indeed, I think it may be more thought-provoking than such labour
declarations as have previously out of the World Social Forum process
(for which check
<u><a href="http://openesf.net/projects/labour-and-globalization/summary">http://openesf.net/projects/labour-and-globalization/summary</a></u>).</p>
<p>	The
final question here must be: what will happen to this text? The Final
Declaration of the conference made no reference to either the text or
the group. But the organisers had at the beginning declared an
intention to either publish all the proceedings or to have them
further developed by individuals or groups over the coming months. I
do not recall the precise proposal. But, in either case, this means
that one is dependent on the goodwill of these organisers (Samir,
François and...?). Unless this occurs transparently, for example via
online discussion, I will not myself find it a satisfactory
procedure. But even if this does occur, I will not find it adequate
if our brief labour chapter, warts and all, is buried in a document
that is generally oriented toward policy questions – however vital.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<h3><strong>The
conference declaration</strong></h3>
<p><strong>	</strong>The
Final Declaration of the conference was submitted to a plenary
session on the last full conference day, where it was subject to
lively discussion. I was dissatisfied by its absence of reference to
the social movements that, presumably, will have to achieve the
socialist transformations it aims at. I therefore proposed an
amendment in some such terms as the following (I do not have a copy
of what I handed in):</p>
<p>
This conference recognises that
the only guarantee for a 21st century socialism is the fullest
development of radical-democratic social movements and a
radical-democratic civil society. This means recognition of and
support to the full range of social movements, such as those for
national self-development, of women, of workers, of indigenous
peoples and sexual minorities, and the constant development of their
terrain of birth and development, that of civil society.</p>
<p>Little
of this can be found in the conference’s final declaration (in
Spanish, <u><a href="http://www.rebelion.org/noticia.php?id=74579">http://www.rebelion.org/noticia.php?id=74579</a></u>),
except in a final clause which says:</p>
<p>
13. …socialism is the
only alternative to solve the set of economic, social, political,
cultural, ecological and civilisational problems of humanity. Its
construction will be the result of the coming together and
mobilisation of workers, peasants, the indigenous, women, social and
environmental movements and other groups which defy injustice to
realise the hopes of the peoples for another possible world.</p>
<p>For
the rest it is a denunciation
of imperialism and capitalism, and praise for a 21<sup>st</sup>
century socialism exemplified by Venezuela, and of which other
examples are apparently to be found in Asia (a Maoist-led Nepal) and
Africa (no cases, fortunately, offered). Regrettably, the conference
organisers seemed unable to adopt a posture of engaged but critical
support for Venezuela (compare, for example, Edgardo Lander,
<u><a href="http://www.tni.org/detail_page.phtml?&amp;act_id=17073&amp;menu=13b">http://www.tni.org/detail_page.phtml?&amp;act_id=17073&amp;menu=13b</a></u>,
Wilpert 2006, Lebowitz 2008).</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<h3>
<strong>Final reflections</strong></h3>
<p>	I
have to agree with a conference friend,
himself an experienced movement coordinator, who angrily denounced
this one as 'old left' in both form and content. It was organised
top-down by a small and self-appointed group of individuals, lacking
any accountability or transparency, dependent financially and
therefore morally on one state. It was intellectually dominated by
one man, Samir Amin (whose fundamental beliefs seem to have not
changed in the 40 years that I have been following them). I mentioned
above the invisibility of computerisation/informatics/cyberspace in
his and our reflections. But Samir seems to have hardly noted, or
simply dismissed, the new wave of emancipatory thinking and forms of
activity that have accompanied capitalist globalisation and
informatisation. Passing conference references to the World Social
Forum were dismissive, despite Samir being still, I believe, a member
of its International Council. Finally there is the matter of what
will happen with all the effort the 135 often experienced and
sometimes brilliant participants have put into this effort.   I am
wondering whether they would, in any other context, have left their
work to be processed by two, or even 25, veteran male leftists –
however brilliant and cosmopolitan they might happen to be.</p>
<p>	I
tend to agree with my conference friend, except in his anger. I knew
what I was buying. Or, rather - since my costs were paid by the World
Forum of Alternatives, Defence of Humanity and President Chávez –
I knew what I was being paid for.</p>
<p>However,
I have been frequently subsidised, directly or indirectly, for my
participation in WSF and related events, such funding carrying its
own moral burdens.
Moreover, I do think that the WFA has been influenced (if not reborn)
as a result of that 'open space' exemplified by the WSF. And I in any
case appreciate the invitation from people I have been openly
critical of. Finally, I guess, I do not consider the World Social
Forum the <em>only</em>
global space or platform for the development of emancipatory thought
and action in today's world. It, too, has its limitations, in no
small part due to a certain 'openspaceism' which encourages, if it
does not promote, the idea that Dialogue is All - rather than simply
necessary to a new movement of global social emancipation. Left
labour initiatives within the WSF seem to me so far constrained by
their concern to avoid offence to the hegemonic union
inter/nationals, even where the latter are deeply, if not totally,
self-subordinated to partnership with corporations and states that
are destroying not simply worker conditions and union rights but the
social and natural conditions for existence on this planet (but see
the newest WSF labour initiative <strong>Appendix
C</strong>).</p>
<p>	As
our labour group in Caracas continued to meet, formally and
informally, I began to think that we should see the conference as a
possible launching pad rather than an imprisoning container. My own
'minimum' and 'maximum' projects at present are for an open,
autonomous, transparent and relevant international labour web space
(minimum) and for a Global Labour charter (maximum) – indeed for
any such charter that might surpass the notion that capital and state
can make work 'decent'. Models for such are provided by the Women’s
Global Charter for Humanity (2005) and the Casino Crash Declaration
(2008). The first model is of interest for the dialogue that preceded
its formulation. The latter is of interest for being immediately
published, on the web, for approval and discussion (99 responses in
the first week).</p>
<p>	This
short note,
with its extended resources and appendices, is intended to advance
this admittedly ambitious effort.</p>
<p>
Critical feedback would be
welcome.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<h3>
Resource List</h3>
<p>
Amin, Samir.
(2006), ‘Towards the Fifth International?’
<u><a href="http://www.forumtiersmonde.net/fren/index.php?view=article&amp;catid=52%3Acontributions&amp;id=120%3Atowards-the-fifth-international&amp;option=com_content&amp;Itemid=114">http://www.forumtiersmonde.net/fren/index.php?view=articlecatid=52%3Acontributions&amp;id=120%3Atowards-the-fifth-international&amp;option=com_content&amp;Itemid=114</a></u>.</p>
<p>
Amin, Samir. 2006. ‘What
Maoism Has Contributed’. <u><a href="http://www.monthlyreview.org/0906amin.htm">http://www.monthlyreview.org/0906amin.htm</a></u></p>
<p>
Amin, Samir.
(2007), ‘The
World Social Forum and Popular Struggles: Is the World Social Forum
of use for popular struggles? Are the social forum formulas adequate
to that effect?
<u><a href="http://www.codesria.org/Links/Publications/bulletin1_07/amin.pdf">http://www.codesria.org/Links/Publications/bulletin1_07/amin.pdf</a></u></p>
<p>
Amin, Samir. 2008. ‘Transiciones
y alternativas en debate’ (Transitions and Alternatives Under
Discussion), <em>America Latina in
Movimiento</em>, No. 436. 32 pages.</p>
<p>
Aponte, Antonio. ‘Magnicidio Politicó’
(Assasination of a Political Leader), <em>Diario
Vea</em>, October 16, p. 9.</p>
<p>
Bieler, Andreas, Ingemar Lindberg and Devan Pillay
(eds). 2008. <em>Labour and the Challenges
of Globalisation: What Prospects for Transnational Solidarity?</em>.
London: Pluto.</p>
<p>
Casino Crash.
2008. ‘The
Global Economic Crisis: An Historic Opportunity for Transformation’,
(Beijing, October 15). <u><a href="http://casinocrash.org/?p=235#comments">http://casinocrash.org/?p=235#comments</a></u>.</p>
<p>
Castells,
Manuel. 1996-7.
‘ The Information Age: Economy, Society and Culture’,
Cambridge, MA; Oxford, UK: Blackwell. 3 Vols.</p>
<p>
Haworth, Nigel and
Harvie Ramsay. 1984. ‘Grasping the Nettle: Problems in the Theory
of International Labour Solidarity’ in Peter Waterman (ed) <em>For
A New Labour Internationalism</em>, The
Hague. ILERI.</p>
<p>
Lander, Greg.
2006. ‘The
Meaning of 21st Century Socialism for Venezuela’,
Venezuelanalysis.com, 11 July,
<u><a href="http://www.venezuelanalysis.com/analysis/1834">http://www.venezuelanalysis.com/analysis/1834</a></u>.</p>
<p>
Lebowitz,
Michael. ‘The Spectre of Socialism for the 21st Century’,
 <u><a href="http://links.org.au/node/503/1594%20#comment-1594">http://links.org.au/node/503/1594
#comment-1594</a></u>.</p>
<p>
Red de
Intelectuales y Artistas en Defensa de Humanidad.
<u><a href="http://humanidadenred.org/index.php?%20option=com_frontpage&amp;Itemid=1">http://humanidadenred.org/index.php?
option=com_frontpage&amp;Itemid=1</a></u>.</p>
<p>
Sen,
Jai and Mahuresh Kumar (with Patrick Bond and Peter Waterman) (eds).
2007. <em>A
Political Programme for the World Social Forum? Democracy, Substance
and Debate in the Bamako Appeal and the Global Justice Movements.</em>
New Delhi and Durban: CACIM and Centre for Civil Society.
<u><a href="http://openspaceforum.net/twiki/tiki-print.php?page=BAReader">http://openspaceforum.net/twiki/tiki-print.php?page=BAReader</a></u>.</p>
<p>
Waterman,
Peter. 2005. ‘From “Decent Work” to “The Liberation of Time
from Work”: Reflections on Work, Emancipation, Utopia and the
Global Justice and Solidarity Movement’,
<u><a href="http://info.interactivist.net/article.pl?sid=05/03/24/170247&amp;mode=nested&amp;tid=4">http://info.interactivist.net/article.pl?sid=05/03/24/170247&amp;mode=nested&amp;tid=4</a></u></p>
<p>
Waterman,
Peter. 2008a. ‘Labour@ESF
Malmo, September 2008: Work and/or Life?’. http://www.choike.
org/documentos/labour-esf2008.pdf</p>
<p>
Waterman,
Peter. 2008b.
'The
Fifth International: A
19<sup>th</sup>
Century Answer to a 21<sup>st</sup>
Century Problem’ (Unpublished Draft)</p>
<p>
Waterman,
Peter. 2008c.
‘Needed: A Global Labour Charter Movement’.
<u><a class="external-link" href="../../ projekte/waterman/gc.">http://www.netzwerkit.de/
projekte/waterman/gc</a></u>.</p>
<p>
WFA (World Forum for Alternatives). 1997. ‘World
Forum for Alternatives Manifesto’, 
<a class="external-link" href="http://www.ecn.wfu.edu/~cottrell/ope/archive/9706/0057.html">http://www.ecn.wfu.edu/~cottrell/ope/archive/9706/0057.html</a>.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<h3>Appendix
A</h3>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p align="center">
<strong>Conference on ‘Union Alliances
with Social Movements: What's in It for Us’?</strong></p>
<p align="center">
<strong>Transport workers to home in on
social movements</strong></p>
<p align="center">
[Announcement on the website of the
International Transport Workers Federation, 17 September 2008]</p>
<p>
Road transport workers will be
looking at ways of building alliances with social movements at a
special conference in Norway next month.</p>
<p>
The
conference, organised by the ITF-affiliated Norwegian union
Fagforbundet in cooperation with the ITF, is to be held in Oslo from
16-17 October. It will give workers the chance to examine new ways of
facing the challenges that have emerged over the past 30 years, which
include form alliances with other movements. The event will also
focus on the possibility of unions taking on a broader perspective in
their everyday activities.</p>
<p>
Speakers at the conference
include: Professor Ronaldo Munck, Dublin City University, who will
discuss globalisation, labour and trade unions and Mac Urata, ITF
Inland Transport Section Secretary, who will focus on the ITF and
global action campaigns. Meanwhile Mike Waghorne, former Assistant
General Secretary, PSI and Asbjørn Wahl, Adviser, Fagforbundet, and
Alexandra Strickner, Attac Austria, will look at trade unions and
social movements.</p>
<p>
ITF Inland
Transport Section Secretary Mac Urata commented: “Affiliates
endorsed a proposal to review trade unions’ global action-oriented
campaigns and the wider social movement. This conference is part of
that process. The mix of speakers from both trade unions and social
movements will hopefully provide participants with new ideas for
working with organisations with similar aims. These alliances could
help tackle the issues facing workers as a result of globalisation
more effectively.”
<u><a href="http://www.itfglobal.org/news-online/index.cfm/newsdetail/2587">http://www.itfglobal.org/news-online/index.cfm/newsdetail/2587</a></u></p>
<p align="center">
<strong>[Report on the website of the
International Transportworkers Federation, October 20, 2008]</strong></p>
<p>
Unionists, NGO members and
academics met in Oslo on 17 and 18 October 2008 to discuss the
cooperations that trade unions and the wider social movement can
develop. The meeting, co-hosted by the ITF and the Norwegian
affiliate, Fagforbundet (the Norwegian Union of Municipal and General
Employees), stressed informalisation of employment and
internationalisation of production as two key features that trade
unions face today. It also highlighted that trade union membership is
declining in many countries and the unions' traditional relationship
with the political parties is changing. However, some unions are
fighting back against neo-liberal attacks&nbsp;and several examples
were reported. These included the campaign for welfare state in
Norway; strategic campaigning in the US Teamsters union; awareness
raising of members and support to the Baltic unions network by the
Swedish Transport Workers' Union, to name a few. The participants
agreed that unions and the social movement can work together if they
can share their information, accept their differences but ensure that
their capacities are fully used. It resolved to hold thematic
meetings for example, on climate change in transport, as well as to
encourage the ITF to discuss the question of collaboration with the
social movement regularly in their meetings. Mac Urata and Asbjørn
Wahl co-chaired the meeting. (Email report by Claire Clarke).
<u><a href="http://www.itfglobal.org/campaigns/RoadActionWeek2008-20October.cfm">http://www.itfglobal.org/campaigns/RoadActionWeek2008-20October.cfm</a></u>.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<h3>
Appendix B</h3>
<p align="center">
<strong>6. To Build
a Workers’ United Front</strong></p>
<p align="center">[Labour
Chapter of the Bamako Appeal 2005]</p>
<p>
Two of the
principal weapons in the hands of workers are the right to vote and
the right to form trade unions. Up to now democracy and trade unions
were built mainly within the national states. Now, however,
neo-liberal globalisation has challenged the workers the world over,
and globalised capitalism cannot be confronted at the national level
alone. Today, the task is twofold: to strengthen organising on a
national level and simultaneously globalise democracy and reorganise
a worldwide working class.</p>
<p>
Mass
unemployment and the increasing proportion of informal work
arrangements are other imperative reasons to reconsider the existing
organisations of the laboring classes. A world strategy for labor
must consider not only the situation of workers who work under stable
contracts. Employment out of the formal sectors now involves an
increasing portion of workers, even in the industrialised countries.
In the majority of the countries of the South, the workers of the
informal sector – temporary labor, informal labor, the
self-employed, the unemployed, street salespeople, those who sell
their own services — together form the majority of the laboring
classes. These groups of informal workers are growing in the majority
of the countries of the South because of high unemployment and a
two-sided process: on the one hand, the decreasing availability of
guaranteed employment and increased informal employment, and on the
other hand, the continuous migration from the rural areas to the
towns. The most important task will be for workers outside the formal
sector to organise themselves and for the traditional trade unions to
open up in order to carry out common actions.</p>
<p>
The
traditional trade unions have had problems responding to this
challenge. Not all the organisations of the workers - except in the
formal sectors - will necessarily be trade unions or similar
organisations and the traditional trade unions will also have to
change. New perspectives for organising together, based on horizontal
bonds and mutual respect, must develop between the traditional trade
unions and the new social movements. For this purpose, the following
proposals are submitted for consideration:</p>
<ol><li>
An
opening of the trade unions towards collaboration with the other
social movements without trying to subordinate them to the
traditional trade-union structure or a specific political party.</li><li>The
constitution of effectively transnational trade-union
structures in order to confront transnational employers. These
trade-union structures should have a capacity to negotiate and at the
same time have a mandate to organise common actions beyond national
borders. For this purpose, an important step would be to organise
strong trade-union structures within transnational corporations.
These corporations have a complex network of production and are often
very sensitive to any rupture in the chains of production and
distribution, that is, they are vulnerable. Some successes in the
struggles against the transnational corporations
could have a real impact on the world balance of power between
capital and labor.</li><li>Technological development and structural change are necessary to
improve living conditions and eradicate poverty, but the relocations
of production are not carried out today in the interest of the
workers; instead, they are exclusively profit-driven. It is necessary
to promote a gradual improvement of the wages and working conditions,
to expand local production along with local demand and a system of
negotiation to carry out relocation in other ways than simply
following the logic of profit and free trade. These relocations could
fit under transnational negotiation in order to prevent workers of
the various countries from being forced to enter in competition with
each other in a relentless battle.</li><li>To
consider the rights of migrant worker as a basic concern for the
trade unions by ensuring that solidarity among workers is not
dependent on their national origin. Indeed, segregation and
discrimination on ethnic or other bases are threats to working-class
solidarity.</li><li>To take
care so that the future transnational organisation of the laboring
class is not conceived as a unique, hierarchical and pyramidal
structure, but as a variety of various types of organisations, with a
network-like structure with many horizontal bonds.</li><li>To
promote a labor front in reorganised structures that also include
workers outside the formal sector throughout the world, capable of
Ttaking effective coordinated actions to confront globalised
capitalism.</li></ol>
<p>Only
such a renewed movement of workers, worldwide, inclusive and acting
together with other social movements will be able to transform the
present world and to create a world order founded on solidarity
rather than on competition.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<h3>Appendix C<br /></h3>
<p>-----
Original Message -----</p>
<p><strong>From:</strong>
<u><a href="mailto:marco.berlinguer@transform.it">Marco
Berlinguer</a></u></p>
<p><strong>To:</strong>
<u><a href="mailto:esflabourandglobalization@lists.openesf.net">Labour&amp;GlobalizationESF</a></u>
; <u><a href="mailto:wsflabourandglobalization@lists.openesf.net">Labour&amp;GlobalizationWSF</a></u></p>
<p><strong>Cc:</strong>
<u><a href="mailto:Lavoro-in-Movimento@googlegroups.com">Lavoro
in Movimento mailing list</a></u></p>
<p><strong>Sent:</strong>
Monday, October 27, 2008 10:18 AM</p>
<p><strong>Subject:</strong>
[ESF Labour &amp; Globalization] Labor and Globalization Network
Toward the WSF</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p align="center">
<strong>LABOR AND
GLOBALIZATION (L&amp;G) NETWORK</strong></p>
<p align="center">
<strong>TOWARD THE 2009 WSF</strong></p>
<p align="center"><strong>REPORT
OF THE WORKING GROUP</strong></p>
<p>This is a proposed work
plan for the Labor and Globalization (L&amp;G) Network for the next
World Social Forum (WSF). It is the result of the discussion we had
in the European Social Forum (ESF) L&amp;G meeting and of a
collective contribution by a working group composed of Pat Horn
(StreetNet, South Africa) , Kjeld Jakobsen (Observatorio Social/CUT,
Brazil), Tim Costello (Global Labor Strategies, USA), Alexandra
Strickner (ATTAC – OWINFS, Austria), Bruno Ciccaglione (SDL,
Italia) and Marco Berlinguer (Transform! – Lavoro in
Movimento/CGIL, Italia).</p>
<p><strong>PROPOSAL</strong></p>
<p>A)&nbsp; The network
will promote directly and independently two activities to help build
the identity of the network and to make progress in establishing a
concrete agenda for the future of the network.</p>
<p>B)&nbsp;&nbsp; The network
will focus its main effort into putting the current economic
crisis—and political interventions to address it—at the centre of
the WSF in cooperation with all the other organizations and networks
wish to participate.</p>
<p>C)&nbsp;&nbsp; The network
will encourage and serve as facilitator for communication and
cooperation on initiatives on other key themes in the WSF.</p>
<p><u>Initiatives</u></p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p><strong>A</strong><em><strong>.</strong></em><em>
The two proposed activities</em></p>
<p>1)&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The
L&amp;G Network will create a meeting space for the convergence of
representatives of the different of types of labor in the global
economy, in both in the formal and the informal sector. The space is
aimed to investigate the "commons"—and the
differences--across the different forms of labor.</p>
<p>Method: A synthetic text
will be written in the next weeks. It will then be widely circulated
as draft discussion paper among diverse groups representing, or
allied with, workers employed in different forms of employment.
Comments, additions, and new ideas will be collected and a revised
draft will be written and circulated before the WSF in Belem.&nbsp;
Following the discussions at WSF the text will be revised again in a
process that will continue with the goal of collectively writing a
charter, manifesto, or declaration on labor in the era of
globalization.</p>
<p>The contact person
and coordinator of this activity is Pat Horn&nbsp;- StreetNet –
email: <u><a href="mailto:stnet@iafrica.com" target="_blank">stnet@iafrica.com</a></u></p>
<p>2)&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;
Create an assembly of the L&amp;G Network itself aimed at discussing
a basic plan and organization for the work of the network after the
WSF: its articulation, enlargement, objectives, web tools, and
agenda.</p>
<p>Method: A written proposal
will be circulated before the WSF in order to collect comments,
suggestions and contributions which can be discussed by each
individual organization. The aim is to arrive at the WSF assembly
with the possibility and capacity to make decisions.</p>
<p>The contact person
and coordinator of this activity is Kjeld Jakobsen&nbsp;-
Observatorio Social – email: <u><a href="mailto:kjeld@observatoriosocial.org.br" target="_blank">kjeld@observatoriosocial.org.br</a></u></p>
<p><strong>B.</strong>
<em>The focus on the current economic
crisis</em>&nbsp;</p>
<p>The L&amp;G Network will
propose a plan of convergence about the global financial and
economical crisis, to many other organizations and networks in global
movements interested in creating at the WSF a common space of
analysis, discussion and, where possible, of intervention.</p>
<p>Method: the circulation of
written analyses and proposals on the crisis will be encouraged
before the WSF. The L&amp;G Network will propose to jointly set up at
the WSF an activity lasting all the three days, to progressively
deepen – as far as possible – a common understanding of the
crisis and of a plan of intervention to address it.</p>
<p>The contact person
and coordinator for this activity is Marco Berlinguer –
Transform!/Lavoro in Movimento - email: <u><a href="mailto:marco.berlinguer@transform.it" target="_blank">marco.berlinguer@transform.it</a></u></p>
<p><strong>C.</strong>&nbsp;
<em>Other initiatives</em></p>
<p>The L&amp;G Network and
its e-lists will serve to facilitate the communication and
cooperation of initiatives in the WSF. Key themes already raised and
proposed are: Migrants, Ecological Modes of Production, and
International Trade.</p>
<p>&nbsp;<strong>PRACTICALITIES</strong></p>
<p>The CGIL will register the
network and its two planned activities.</p>
<p>All the organizations
interested in participating in the activities proposed by the network
are asked to contact the coordinators (Pat, Kjeld, Marco) to
participate in the process of inscriptions and merging.</p>
<p>Kjeld Jakobsen will
oversee the process of merging and finalization of the activities
promoted by the networks.</p>
<p>&nbsp;<strong>FUNDING TRIPS IN
THE GLOBAL SOUTH</strong></p>
<p>We need to make the
maximum effort to fund the trips of some people and organizations
from the Global South. All the organizations that can help are
invited to establish a contact with Pat Horn (<u><a href="mailto:stnet@iafrica.com" target="_blank">stnet@iafrica.com</a></u>).</p>
<p><strong>ENLARGING THE L&amp;G
NETWORK </strong></p>
<p>We would like to
expand the network along with the process of preparation of the next
WSF. If you would like to include new members on the e-lists of L&amp;G,
send details to Marco. (<u><a href="mailto:marco.berlinguer@transform.it" target="_blank">marco.berlinguer@transform.it</a></u>)</p>
<p>&nbsp;<strong>IMPORTANT
REMINDER</strong></p>
<p>Remember that the
inscriptions of organizations and proposals of activities at the WSF
are already opened and will close on the 7th of November</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<h3>Appendix D</h3>
<p align="center"><strong>Summary
of discussion in the Caracas Labour Group 2008:</strong></p>
<p align="center"><strong>Towards
the Global Emancipation of Labour</strong></p>
<p>The
group consisted of about 25 members and decided to stay together and
discuss all three questions in plenary</p>
<p>The
<em>three
questions</em>
set by the organisers were as follows:</p>
<ul><li>
The increasingly
'informalisation' of labour</li><li>
The challenge of global labour
solidarity</li><li>
New forms of labour
self-organisation</li></ul>
<p>The group touched on the current
crisis of capitalist globalisation. That this is bound to hit labour;
there will be job losses and greater insecurity of jobs. The serious
capitalist economic crisis, whose first expression was in the
financial area, will eventually move into the productive area and
aggravate the class struggle on a worldwide scale. Big capital plans
to make workers around the world  pay the costs of this crisis, and
to transfer the costs as much as possible from the industrialised
countries to those countries on the periphery. The capitalist
offensive to impose an authoritarian restructuring of its domination
hits the working class in a period when the organisational and
ideological level of the workers is low, except in certain  nations
where advances have been made, for example, in Bolivia and Venezuela.</p>
<p>However the changes in the modes
of labour have been happening over a much longer period. In most
countries the number of what is called informal labour, far outnumber
the formal sector. The main struggles are against retrenchment and
job losses. Unemployment, informalisation, casualisation, migration-
these are the issues that face labour today. In the last few decades
there  have been many profound changes in the internal structure of
the working class, brought about through the  neoliberal offensive,
the development of the productive forces and the institutional
changes that imposed labor flexibility. Today's working class is
composed of industrial workers and public service workers  who still
have secure jobs and labor rights, together with a massive number of
workers in insecure jobs, mainly young people, women, and immigrant
workers with and without work papers and "underground"
workers (the latter suffer what are near slave worker conditions).</p>
<p>These changes have also meant
that there needs to be a re-conceptualisation of work and working
class.</p>
<p>The group discussed the need (or
not) to redefine the meaning of ‘work’ and 'worker’ . Work is
more than just that of the traditional industrial or clerical
workplace, and the definition of worker has to be more comprehensive.
This includes not only workers in the formal sector, but also labour
in the informal sector,  for example the case of street traders, poor
peasants, call-centre workers, care-givers, etc. These are also the
sections which have not been widely unionised. Are they part of the
working class or not? Are food- producers part of the working class?
This is an important question – the one of definition - which has
strategic implications. There was broad consensus that the concept of
working class has to be expanded. That the wage relationship is not
the only factor that defines the working class. But there were many
questions still to be debated at length.</p>
<p>There was a debate on whether
ownership of the means of production can be considered as criteria
for defining a set of people as being part of the class. The street
hawker, the tailor who owns a sewing machine- can he/she be
considered to be part of the proletariat? Some felt that the classic
definition of the proletariat was important in a strategic way.
Others felt that a wider definition was needed.</p>
<p>The question of self-perception
is also interesting. It was noted that often even sections of the
working class no longer see themselves as part of the class, and
instead identify themselves as middle class or merely  part of a
particular trade or profession. Street vendors even though they are
often out of work workers, see themselves as small businesspeople.
Call-centre employees do not still see themselves as workers.</p>
<p>There was an exchange of
experiences in the different countries: China, India, Philipines,
South Africa, various parts of Europe and Africa. Everywhere we see
increasing heterogeneity and fragmentation of labour.</p>
<p>But the working class survives,
and struggles continue, often using new forms of organisation and
struggle. In Germany workers fought against neo-liberal reforms which
affect all the people not only workers. In Brussels the trade unions
are still organised and strong even if the leadership is not always
socialist. In China if there are no huge protests against growing
unemployment, and forced migration, it is only because the villages
provide family and community support. This is the case in many third
world countries. In Brazil and India we see new and effective forms
of workers struggle and organisation. In the US immigrant workers
have been at the forefront of working class struggles, and have
revived the May Day tradition in the USA.</p>
<p>There are important problems in
maintaining the independence of the working class to the extent that
governments claim they are  defenders of the popular interests. The
government's goal is to turn the labor movement into a factor to
assure social peace when confronted with proposals that threaten the
interests of the working class and the people. In their structure and
function, many labor confederations have stopped representing the
interests of the new working class in all its heterogenity, and now
consist of non-representative top-down structures.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p>In this crisis scenario there
must be an amplification and intensification of labor struggle that
take the most diverse forms and in this way advance toward a struggle
for socialism that will be capable in the 21st century of offering an
alternative contrary to the destructive logic of the capitalist
system. On the road toward the ideological and organisational
reconstruction of the working class, a central aspect is the
development of a movement based on workers' democracy - with the
direct participation of the workers in taking fundamental decisions.
This will raise the level of class consciousness, class unity and
capacity for struggle.</p>
<p>We noted that new struggles and
forms of organisation evolved; going beyond the organisation of
traditional unions to deal with the new forms of labour, and to unify
the struggles of the different sections of the working class. This
does not however mean that the trade unions are obsolete or even
ineffective. In many parts of Europe major sections of the working
class are still organised in trade unions and even where the
leadership is not socialist, the potential and power of these
organisations are still significant and we must not fall into the
neo-liberal trap of discounting their importance. The working class
should integrate its distinct form of organisation, starting from the
traditional kind of workers' unions, to include movements of
unemployed, precarious and immigrant and clandestine workers, into
united actions of the working class in its broadest definition, in
particular in defense of the working class sectors with the least
protection.</p>
<p>A union movement should have the
capacity of coordinating with other social sectors in concrete
struggle that concern each of these sectors, including the movement
against war. In the struggle for democracy - using its broadest
political, economic and social meaning - the working class must try
to coordinate with other social sectors, without losing its class
identity or independence.</p>
<p>There was a discussion on what
can be called the hierarchy of class consciousness. Some felt that
the struggles of the indigenous people, and small and marginal
farmers for land and natural resources have been the most
revolutionary struggles in recent history and terming them as
petty-bourgeois somehow seems to relegate them to second place; it
does not help in order to fully understand and analyse the huge
potential and impact of these struggles, e.g. in Bolivia.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p>New
forms of organisation can be seen in the struggles of the unemployed,
informal, migrants etc. Existing trade unions, too, are forced to
adopt new methods to organise or relate to these sectors. Often
however these movements are outside of the formal trade union
framework, and they are more like social movements, community
organisations or NGOs. These struggles include those around
unemployment, privatisation, public transport, environmental justice,
housing, local economic activities, cooperatives, etc. There is a new
kind of social movement unionism that goes beyond the workplace that
seems to have become effective in conditions where workers are thrown
out of work, or where they forge a wider unity in the community. Also
where workers organise themselves as citizens to deal with more than
the problems of the workplace. The struggles against unemployment
provide a rich source of information and inspiration, e.g. the
<em>piquetero</em>
movement in Argentina, the marches in Europe, and struggles in
various part of the world.</p>
<p>There were different views on the
centrality of struggle of the working class. For some in the struggle
for the destruction/replacement of capitalism, the new working class,
now heterogenous and fragmented, has a central role, because it
creates all weath, and builds links of solidarity, collective
organisation, and because it is conscious of its potential for
radically transforming society. It must find a way to coordinate with
other popular sectors and social movements, respecting their
diversity, but searching for forms of united struggle against
capitalism. The conditions of gender, ethnic group, age, nationality
also have a class character that makes the construction of unity
through struggle possible. For others any centrality is out of the
question.</p>
<p>The struggles around the
reduction of hours of work at the workplace are important in the
current scenario. Not only because of the crisis and the need for
workers to respond to it in the more advanced capitalist countries
but because it can also help to humanise the life of the worker. This
is also a project in Venezuela. Here less hours at the workplace does
not mean less hours of work- it merely means different kinds of work:
education, care-giving, etc, which are also work which has social
value.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p>The working-class movement needs
to know about and be inspired by the new developments in various
parts of the world, e.g. Venezuela, Bolivia, where there have been
experiences inspired by ideas and practices of a post-capitalist or
socialist project. In Venezuela workers are being organised in
communal councils, which provide for representation of informal
workers who may not be organised in traditional unions. These
councils have been linked to those in occupied factories. Also there
are discussions around the shortening of the hours of work in the
workplace but spending the rest of the hours in community work,
skills and education, care-giving, etc</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p>Increasing importance of global
solidarity: This becomes ever more crucial under capitalist
globalisation. This does not mean that it is easy. Its forms too are
disputed.</p>
<p>There have been experiences of
successful global strike actions coordinated over more than one
country.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p>Where workers see themselves and
are organised as human-beings and citizens the possibilities of
solidarity are considerably enhanced. Common campaigns include those
around peace and security, global warming, democracy, privatisation,
trade, global financial architecture, global social wage, etc.</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p><br />
           The working class should work in a united way nationally
and internationally to prevent the capitalists from passing the costs
of the crisis onto the workers' backs. To do this we propose the
following concrete demands:</p>
<blockquote>
<ul><li>
Moratorium on the external debt
to finance the budgets aimed at providing the basic necessities of
the population and the subsidies for access to products of primary
necessity.</li><li>
Moratorium on payment of
mortgages and rents and suspension of evictions with the goal of
guaranteeing the right to housing.</li><li>
Price controls and other means to
avoid letting inflation reduce the buying power of workers retired
people.</li><li>
Control of changing and
circulation of capital to avoid letting the industrialised countries
seize the wealth of the countries in the periphery.&nbsp;</li></ul>
</blockquote>
<p>There are many different
understandings about the meaning of solidarity. There can be tension
between class solidarity and anti-imperialist solidarity. Thus, there
was a debate on whether solidarity actions may be inopportune because
they reinforce the game and the agenda of  imperialism, or from
another perspective anti-worker and anti-people regimes are excused
on the basis that they are anti-imperialist. In any case we have to
be aware that imperialist forces may well be conspiring against these
regimes. These issues need to be further discussed more extensively.</p>
<p>
There is a need to unify
working-class struggles and to have more coordination and exchanges
between the different countries. It's important to note that the
churches have sometimes had more success in uniting workers than the
left has had. The current institutions like the ILO are failing to do
this. There was criticism of the Decent Work campaign initiated by
the ILO - the feeling being that it tries to restore a past utopia of
labour-capital relations that neo-liberal globalisation has put into
profound question. There were suggestions about necessity of a global
charter for migrant workers or even a Global Charter for Workers more
generally.</p>
<p>
There is a need to link
working-class issues with those of ecology, and other issues to make
the struggles  more universal, effective and relevant.</p>
<p>
The issue of migration was seen
as one of the most critical issues facing workers today, in every
part of the globe. This includes not only cross-border but also
internal displacement. There is a need for a methodology and a
machinery to deal with this issue.</p>
<div id="sdfootnote1">
<p class="sdfootnote"><a class="sdfootnotesym" name="sdfootnote1sym" href="#sdfootnote1anc">1</a>
	Appreciation
	must be expressed for rapid feedback from Patrick Bond, Rosalba
	Icaza, Gina Vargas and John Catalinotto. They cannot, of course, be
	held responsible for any use I have made of their contributions.</p>
</div>
]]></content:encoded>
    <dc:publisher>No publisher</dc:publisher>
    <dc:creator>Peter Waterman</dc:creator>
    <dc:rights></dc:rights>
    <dc:date>2008-10-29T13:24:45Z</dc:date>
    <dc:type>Seite</dc:type>
  </item>




</rdf:RDF>
